10 Most Enchanting Castles in America: The Hidden Fortresses of the New World

Most Enchanting Castles in America

Standing atop the battlements of Hearst Castle, gazing out over the sun-drenched California coastline, a realization struck me like a medieval battering ram: Europe doesn’t have a monopoly on fairy tale fortresses. America boasts its own crop of castles, transporting visitors to a world of turrets, tapestries, and timeless charm – often with a uniquely American twist.

Polish your armor and prepare for a journey through the hidden realm of American castles. From coast to coast, these 10 magnificent structures prove that regal splendor doesn’t require a passport. Just bring a good pair of walking shoes and a willingness to suspend disbelief when encountering a castle in, say, Oklahoma.

Hearst Castle – San Simeon, California

Hearst Castle Pool

Our tour begins where this castle epiphany occurred: the legendary Hearst Castle. Perched high above the Pacific Ocean like a glittering mirage, this Mediterranean Revival masterpiece embodies newspaper tycoon William Randolph Hearst’s fever dream brought to stunning life.

The estate sprawls across 127 acres, with the main house – “La Casa Grande” – boasting 68,500 square feet and 38 bedrooms. To put that in perspective, it’s about 30 times the size of a typical New York apartment, with 37 more functional bathrooms.

Construction spanned nearly 30 years, beginning in 1919. Hearst collaborated with architect Julia Morgan to create his “Enchanted Hill,” a playground for Hollywood elite and political bigwigs. The guest list read like a Who’s Who of the early 20th century: Charlie Chaplin, Cary Grant, Winston Churchill, and even Calvin Coolidge (though he likely livened up the party about as much as a medieval chastity belt).

The crown jewel is the outdoor Neptune Pool, an enormous Greco-Roman-inspired swimming pool that dwarfs any backyard inflatable. One half expects Zeus himself to emerge from the turquoise waters, possibly sporting Hearst-brand swim trunks.

Opulent rooms, each more lavishly decorated than the last, evoke a mix of awe and amusement. Hearst’s collection of European art and antiques impresses, yet there’s something delightfully absurd about ancient Roman statues rubbing shoulders with 1920s Hollywood glamour. It’s as if the Colosseum decided to host the Oscars.

Boldt Castle – Alexandria Bay, New York

From California’s sun-soaked hills, we journey to the mist-shrouded shores of the Thousand Islands region in upstate New York. Here, on Heart Island in the St. Lawrence River, stands Boldt Castle – a monument to love that would soften even the most cynical New Yorker’s heart.

The main castle covers 29,000 square feet, with 120 rooms spread across six stories. That’s ample space for romantic gestures, or for hiding when one has forgotten an anniversary.

George Boldt, proprietor of the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel, began construction in 1900 as a lavish gift for his beloved wife, Louise. Tragedy struck in 1904 when Louise suddenly passed away, leading a heartbroken Boldt to halt all work on the castle. For 73 years, it stood abandoned, a Sleeping Beauty of the St. Lawrence, until the Thousand Islands Bridge Authority acquired and began restoring it in 1977.

The Power House, designed to resemble a medieval fortress, stands out as a unique attraction. This modern marvel once housed a generator to supply the entire island with electricity – proving that even in matters of the heart, Boldt remained practical enough to keep the lights on.

Exploring the castle’s nooks and crannies evokes a twinge of both romance and melancholy. The grand ballroom, never graced by the swish of Louise’s gowns, now echoes with tourists’ footsteps. Carefully manicured gardens invite visitors to imagine George and Louise strolling arm in arm, blissfully unaware of their love’s bittersweet legacy.

Castello di Amorosa – Calistoga, California

If Hearst Castle is California’s ode to Mediterranean grandeur, then Castello di Amorosa serves as its love letter to medieval Tuscany – with a dash of Napa Valley flair. After all, what says “authentic 13th-century Italian castle” quite like a world-class winery?

This sprawling fortress covers 121,000 square feet, with 107 rooms spread across 8 levels (4 above ground, 4 below). Such expansive space easily disorients visitors after a few too many wine tastings.

Unlike our previous entries, Castello di Amorosa is a relative newcomer to the American castle scene. Construction began in 1994 and took 14 years to complete, opening to the public in 2007. Owner Dario Sattui, a fourth-generation winemaker, spared no expense in creating an authentically medieval experience – right down to the hand-forged iron maidens in the torture chamber. (Nothing says “buy our Cabernet” quite like a reminder of medieval justice systems.)

The Great Hall stands out as the piece de resistance. Its 22-foot-high coffered ceiling, hand-painted frescoes, and 500-year-old fireplace imported from Italy create the perfect atmosphere for sipping wine and pretending to be a Medici plotting your next political move.

Visitors often find themselves torn between admiration for the craftsmanship and amusement at the project’s sheer audacity. One can’t help but wonder if they age the wine in the dungeons – after all, nothing says “premium vintage” quite like notes of dank stone and echoing screams.

Gillette Castle – East Haddam, Connecticut

From Napa’s vineyards, we venture to Connecticut’s wooded hills, where a castle straight out of a steampunk fever dream awaits. Gillette Castle, former home of actor William Gillette (best known for his portrayal of Sherlock Holmes on stage), exemplifies what happens when a theatrical mastermind designs his dream home.

The castle itself comprises a modest 24 rooms spread over 14,000 square feet, but the estate sprawls across 184 acres of scenic Connecticut woodland. It’s the ideal size for a reclusive actor desiring proximity to nature but distance from adoring fans.

Gillette designed the castle himself and oversaw its construction from 1914 to 1919. A consummate tinkerer, he filled the house with ingenious gadgets and tricks – from secret surveillance mirrors to an intricate system of hidden locks and latches on the 47 doors. One might imagine Sherlock Holmes building a house and then booby-trapping it against Professor Moriarty.

The castle’s miniature railroad stands out as its most unique feature. A three-mile track winds through the estate, upon which Gillette would give his guests rides in custom-built miniature steam locomotives. One can only imagine visitors’ expressions as their eccentric host ushered them onto a tiny train for a grounds tour.

The castle’s quirky interior, with its built-in couches and table-track system for passing the salt, sparks a desire to time-travel and attend one of Gillette’s legendary parties. Picture Connecticut’s elite, dressed in their finest, sipping cocktails while puzzling over how to open a door without triggering some hidden mechanism. It’s like an Agatha Christie novel come to life, minus the murder (one hopes).

Bannerman Castle – Pollepel Island, New York

Our next stop takes us to a crumbling fortress on a tiny Hudson River island, just 60 miles north of New York City. Bannerman Castle resembles less a fairy tale castle and more a fever dream of a Scottish keep crossed with an armory – fitting, given its history.

The main structure, resembling a medieval castle, measures about 180 feet by 68 feet, with towers reaching up to 70 feet high. The island itself spans a mere 6.5 acres, creating the illusion of a fortress rising straight from the river.

Francis Bannerman VI, a Scottish-born military surplus dealer, began construction in 1901. He needed storage for his massive inventory of military equipment (including 30 million surplus cartridges from the Spanish-American War), and what better place than a custom-built castle on a remote island? Unfortunately, a powder explosion in 1920 and a series of fires have left the castle in a haunting state of ruin.

The castle’s very nature as an abandoned military history repository makes it utterly unique. Guided tours now allow visitors to explore the island and learn about its colorful past, though souvenir surplus rifles are, unsurprisingly, not available.

Approaching the island by boat, the castle’s imposing silhouette against the sky sends shivers down one’s spine. It stands as a stark reminder of human ambition’s transient nature – and the dangers of storing too many explosives in one place. Walking among the ruins evokes images of its heyday: a Scottish-style castle in the heart of New York, brimming with weapons and military paraphernalia. One might imagine Braveheart deciding to set up shop in the Hudson Valley.

Fonthill Castle – Doylestown, Pennsylvania

Doylestown, Pennsylvania, houses a castle that appears to have been designed by a medieval architect on an acid trip. Fonthill Castle, the fever dream of archaeologist and tile-maker Henry Chapman Mercer, boasts 44 rooms, 18 fireplaces, and over 200 windows across 20,000 square feet.

Mercer, an eccentric scholar and artisan, built Fonthill between 1908 and 1912 as both his home and a showplace for his extensive tile and print collection. Pioneering reinforced concrete use, Mercer designed and built the castle himself, incorporating his handmade tiles throughout.

The interior’s magic lies in its dizzying mosaic of color and pattern. The Saloon, with its vaulted ceiling and tile-encrusted columns, feels like stepping into a particularly artistic medieval monk’s fever dream.

Wandering through labyrinthine corridors disorients visitors, not just due to the maze-like layout, but from the sheer sensory overload of the decor. One room might feature tiles depicting everything from Norse mythology to Pennsylvania Dutch motifs to scenes from Don Quixote.

Fonthill stands as a testament to one man’s vision, creativity, and apparent disregard for interior design conventions. It’s the architectural equivalent of wearing every piece of jewelry at once – overwhelming, yet admirable in its commitment.

Coral Castle – Homestead, Florida

In sun-drenched Florida, Coral Castle presents a monument to unrequited love and possible alien technology. This structure weighs over 1,100 tons and features massive coral blocks, some weighing up to 30 tons each, all on a humble 3.5-acre plot.

Edward Leedskalnin, a diminutive Latvian immigrant standing 5 feet tall and weighing only 100 pounds, single-handedly built Coral Castle between 1923 and 1951. The method behind this feat remains a mystery, spawning theories ranging from supernatural powers to secret knowledge of magnetism to alien assistance.

The 9-ton gate that moves with a finger’s touch stands out as a highlight, demonstrating Ed’s mysterious engineering mastery. Or perhaps his access to advanced alien technology.

Exploring Coral Castle evokes awe at the achievement and amusement at the wild theories surrounding it. The massive obelisk and perfectly balanced stone rocking chair spark images of Ed working by moonlight, possibly assisted by little green men.

Regardless of its construction method, Coral Castle stands as a testament to human determination – and possibly to the benevolence of our future alien overlords.

Bishop’s Palace – Galveston, Texas

Galveston’s sun-baked shores host the Bishop’s Palace, proving that everything really is bigger in Texas – including, apparently, 19th-century clergymen’s homes.

This Victorian marvel sprawls across 19,000 square feet, with four stories of architectural extravagance. Built between 1887 and 1892 for lawyer and politician Walter Gresham, the house was later purchased by the Roman Catholic Diocese of Galveston, serving as a bishop’s residence until 1963.

The Grand Staircase stands out as a showstopper, featuring intricate wooden carvings, stained glass windows, and enough Victorian opulence to make even the most jaded Downton Abbey fan swoon.

Bishop’s Palace’s resilience sets it apart. Having survived the Great Storm of 1900 – a hurricane that devastated Galveston – the palace symbolizes the city’s strength and endurance.

Touring the rooms, with their intricate plasterwork and rare woods, one imagines the scenes played out here over the years: grand soirees, clandestine meetings, and perhaps the occasional exorcism.

Belvedere Castle – New York City, New York

Belvedere Castle NYC

In Manhattan’s heart, amid towering skyscrapers and bustling streets, lies a fairy tale castle seemingly sprouted from a storybook. Belvedere Castle in Central Park offers New Yorkers a taste of royalty and a respite from hot dog cart aromas.

At a modest 1,300 square feet, Belvedere Castle may be our smallest entry, but it compensates with charm and some of the city’s best views. Designed as a Victorian folly – an ornamental structure meant to add whimsy to the landscape – “Belvedere” aptly means “beautiful view” in Italian.

Since 1919, it has housed the Central Park Weather Station, making it perhaps the only castle worldwide that can report both the current temperature and the best picnic spots.

The castle’s tower offers panoramic views of Central Park and the surrounding cityscape. On clear days, the vista stretches from the Great Lawn to Midtown’s skyscrapers, creating a fairy tale atmosphere amidst yellow cabs and hot dog vendors.

Belvedere Castle represents a place where fantasy and reality collide, where bygone era charm meets modern New York wit.

Thornewood Castle – Lakewood, Washington

Our final stop takes us to American Lake’s misty shores in Washington State. Thornewood Castle stands as a testament to love, determination, and extravagant home decor budgets.

This 27,000 square foot manor boasts 54 rooms, including 22 bedrooms and 22 bathrooms – ample space for elaborate hide-and-seek games or avoiding in-laws during extended family visits.

Built between 1908 and 1911, Thornewood Castle was Chester Thorne’s labor of love for his wife Anna. Thorne, not content with simply building a new house, dismantled a 400-year-old Elizabethan manor in England and had it shipped, brick by brick, to Washington.

The Sunken English Garden, a horticultural marvel designed by the Olmsted Brothers, features over 100 different flower, shrub, and tree species. One imagines Anna Thorne overseeing the planting in a voluminous Edwardian dress, issuing stern commands to bewildered gardeners.

Thornewood’s opulence astounds visitors. The Great Hall features a 500-year-old stained glass window once blessed by the Pope, while the breakfast room ceiling hails from a 17th-century French chateau. It’s as if the Thornes went on a shopping spree through European history.

The castle’s recent claim to fame is its appearance in Stephen King’s TV miniseries “Rose Red.” Now operating as a bed and breakfast, it offers guests a chance to sleep amidst this historical splendor – though ghost sightings aren’t guaranteed, and there’s a strict “no summoning evil spirits” policy.


Castello di Amorosa Castle top view

This grand tour of America’s castles reveals the unique charm each structure possesses. From Hearst Castle’s sun-drenched opulence to Thornewood’s quiet dignity, from Fonthill’s whimsical tiled wonderland to Ed Leedskalnin’s mysterious coral monoliths, these castles embody the diversity and eccentricity of the American spirit.

They stand as testaments to ambition, creativity, and perhaps a touch of madness. What could be more American than building a medieval fortress in Central Park, or shipping an entire English manor across the Atlantic simply because one can?

While lacking the centuries-old pedigrees of their European counterparts, these castles compensate with character. They’re not mere buildings but stories manifested in stone and wood, concrete and coral – dreams given form, ambitions realized, and, in some cases, love letters written on a monumental scale.

So the next time someone claims America lacks real castles, direct them to this list. Just perhaps omit the part about Coral Castle’s aliens to avoid international incidents. After all, what happens in Florida’s mysterious coral fortress stays in Florida’s mysterious coral fortress.

Reflecting on these turreted wonders, one can’t help but smile. In a country known for its forward-thinking attitude and relentless pursuit of the new, these castles serve as delightful reminders that even in America, there’s room for a little old-world magic. Just don’t expect to find any dragons – they couldn’t get through customs.

Share via
Don’t Miss Our Stories
Enter your e-mail below and sign up for our newsletter

I have read and agree to the terms and conditions

Send this to a friend